Porte-Plume
Partager les belles expériences à l’École
Ireland, that small island which seized the opportunity to grow by attracting the tech giants to its shores, but which is now dependent on them.
Like the doc C shows us, an article published the 11th of November 2025 by The Dial, in particular, it highlights the economic priority that the Irish Government has given to the American tech giants. The document D follows a similar idea as document C, this is an editorial cartoon drawn by Harry Burton published on 22 August 2026 by The Irish Examiner, the caricature depicts the Irish government as Zuckerberg’s sycophants (bootlickers), and Tech Giants in general. In opposition document B discusses the opening of a new Meta campus and paints a picture of a perfect Meta. The last one, the document A, is neutral and objective regarding the situation surrounding the purchase of castles in Ireland by tech billionaires. We’re now going to see in which cases the presence of these big companies affects Ireland. By using a three parts plan: in the first one we will see the positive aspect, then the negative one and we will finish with what it can be done nowadays.
From an economic point of view, it is generally a good thing for Ireland to attract Tech Giants to its shores. Ireland is a small isle with fewer resources; the presence of large multinationals is beneficial as it helps to boost its economy and gives it greater influence on the international stage. In addition, It helps to create jobs. Anne O’Leary, Meta’s head of operations in Ireland, says, in doc B, that Meta’s presence and activities provide work for “over 2,000 employees across 80 teams in three Irish locations”. And the opening of their new international headquarters in Dublin will undoubtedly create jobs in the Irish labour market. Moreover, the fact that billionaires bought some castles, helps the country to maintain and preserve its historical heritage. as long as, like Breen says in Document A: "They have a responsibility by buying into these places, these places cannot become billionaire ideals”.
However, not everyone sees this presence as a good thing. The cartoon depicts the Irish government as sycophants of wealthy American businessmen. But why? Because the government grants all their demands for fear that they might leave, and they play on this, as Document C states that Google and Apple had published a report saying that " they could be lured elsewhere at any moment” if the government if the government does not provide sufficient support for AI innovation. Just as with buying castles, tech CEOs don’t do this for the love of culture and history, but to pay less tax and for the status it confers; in Document A, Breen says: “the rich wanted to show their prestige, their standing, and their status within society through the construction of these places”.
Therefore, Ireland should not depend only on tech giants. First of all, the government could help Irish businesses grow. As Document C shows, American companies such as Google and Apple play an important role in the country's economy. If Ireland developed more of its own businesses, it would become less dependent on these multinationals.
Moreover, economic growth does not always benefit everyone. Document B shows that Meta creates jobs in Ireland, especially with its new headquarters in Dublin. However, Document C also highlights the housing problems linked to the presence of tech giants. The government should therefore invest more in housing to help local people and make sure they can also benefit from the country's economic growth.
Finally, Ireland should also protect its historical heritage. Document A discusses Mark Zuckerberg's purchase of an Irish castle, while Document D criticises the influence of wealthy tech billionaires on the Irish government. These documents raise questions about the place of billionaires in Irish society and the protection of the country's interests. The government should therefore make sure that historical buildings are preserved and that decisions are not based only on the interests of wealthy investors.
To conclude, the presence of tech giants in Ireland has both positive and negative effects. While these companies create jobs and contribute to economic growth, they also raise concerns about Ireland's economic dependence, the situation of local people and the protection of its historical heritage. The four documents show that attracting foreign companies can bring important benefits, but it can also create new challenges. Ireland therefore needs to find a balance between economic development and protecting its population, its independence and its cultural heritag